Hello dear
Welcome To Michelli's Pizzeria
Michelli's Pizzeria, located at 145 Palm Bay Rd NE in West Melbourne, FL, is a beloved dining destination known for its exceptional pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the perfect blend of flavors, with highlights including delectable stuffed shells, mouthwatering garlic knots, and cheesy Stromboli that keeps patrons returning week after week. The friendly staff adds to the experience, ensuring diners feel right at home. While there may be occasional wait times, the quality of food far outweighs the inconvenience. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, Michelli's Pizzeria guarantees a satisfying culinary experience that leaves you craving more.
About
Michelli's Pizzeria
Welcome to Michelli's Pizzeria, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of West Melbourne, Florida. Located conveniently at 145 Palm Bay Rd NE Suite 116, this pizzeria has quickly become a staple in the community, renowned for its mouthwatering fare and warm hospitality.
The culinary experience at Michelli's is nothing short of exceptional. As many loyal customers have attested, including Ben Becker, the food here is simply "off the chain good." Whether you're indulging in classic favorites like their stuffed shells or savoring a perfectly baked pizza, every bite promises to deliver a burst of flavor that keeps patrons coming back for more. The presence of regular visitors, who dine here consistently, speaks volumes about the quality and consistency of the dishes on offer.
Pizza aficionados will find themselves in paradise. Reviewers like S Damron and N C rave about the "perfect pizza" and stellar service that accompanies each meal. The attentive staff at Michelli’s adds to the inviting atmosphere, ensuring that your dining experience is smooth and enjoyable. It's not just about the food—the welcoming vibe makes visitors feel right at home.
For those looking for a robust takeout option, Michelli's has garnered a loyal following for their delicious offerings like cheese pizza, Stromboli, and the ever-popular garlic knots paired with creamy Alfredo sauce. Briana Heinl shares her enthusiasm for this triumphant trio, noting that the flavors linger long after the meal is over. Even with minor hiccups in pickup times, the kindness of the staff keeps customers returning with a smile.
Moreover, cleanliness and friendliness are hallmarks of this establishment, as noted by Maryann Anderson. Upon entering Michelli's, you can feel the love and attention that goes into both the food preparation and customer service. You’re not just a customer; you’re part of their community.
To sum it up, Michelli's Pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone in the West Melbourne area. With a combination of delectable dishes, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to quality service, it’s no wonder that this pizzeria has captured the hearts—and stomachs—of so many. Don't just take our word for it; stop by and indulge your taste buds in the flavors of Michelli's. Your next favorite meal awaits!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Was working close by and had to stop back in.. food coma shortly, and had the Stuffed Shells.. OMG. These guys got it dialed in. Exceptional food and sat next to some regulars who eat here every Wednesday.. I know why. The food is off the chain good. Get here!!! ”
“ Perfect pizza and great service. It was a great visit. ”
“ Love it!! Pizza is SOO GOOD!! The salad is great! The one time I sat in they were so attentive! I didn't expect such service! Thanks ladies! ”
“ This is our new favorite takeout pizza place! Our typical order is a cheese pizza, a Stromboli, and garlic knots with Alfredo sauce! I'm drooling just thinking about it! The only reason I didn't give 5 stars to service is bc they seem to be a little off with their pickup time estimates. We have waited 15-20 minutes longer than our estimated pickup window a couple of times. They've always been kind about it, and we try to be understanding and patient. ”
“ I've been there three times to pick up food, and bring home, each time the food was delicious. I will go back again. The cashier's are always friendly. The place also looks very clean. ”
“ I've had Chicago Brick Oven pizza in Chicago and New York Style pizza in New York - but you can save the jet fuel and pick up the best: Right here in West Melbourne! Michelli's pizza is second to none and the service was fast and friendly! ”
“ I came here a little before closing on April 3, 2025. The woman who helped me at the register was so nice and let me order. I'm glad I came here instead of trying the other pizzeria close by. The food was excellent. The crust was perfect, and so were the sauce and seasoning. I could tell the ingredients were high quality. (I ordered the Grandma). I highly recommend this place. The outside appearance of the place is humble but the food is amazing. ”
“ The three of us dined in. It was a Sunday evening, they weren't super busy. We grabbed a table and and sat down. Eileen was our server. She did a great job and had a good sense of humor. The atmosphere was really great and we were laughing a lot having a good time. It's a pretty place and the food was really good. I liked the cheesy garlic bread a lot and that was eaten right away (by me of course!) I didn't want to share it was really good. . For my main meal I had the alfredo sauce pizza and I made a Hawaiian out of it by adding ham bacon and pineapple. The sauce for that pizza was really good. As we were sitting I saw people doing takeout so they do that too. So that's also an option. Anyway there was really delicious food, a great atmosphere and I enjoyed my time here. ”